
Volume Second - Book Eleventh
|
. |
. |
|
|
|
| Chapter 1 | ZWINGLI – HIS DOCTRINE OF THE LORD'S SUPPER. Turn Southward – Switzerland – Reformation from Above – Ulric Zwingli – His Preparation – Resume of his Career – The Foreign Service – The Gospel the Cure of his Nation's Evils – Zwingli at Zurich – His varied Qualities – Transformation of Switzerland – A Catastrophe near – The Lord's Supper – Transubstantiation – Luther's Views – Calvin's Views, Import of the Lord's Supper on the Human Side, Its Import on the Divine Side – Zwingli's Avoidance of the two Extremes as regards the Lord's Supper. |
| Chapter 2 | DISPUTATION AT BADEN AND ITS RESULTS. Alarm of the Romanists – Resolve to Strike a great Blow – They propose a Public Disputation – Eck chosen as Romanist Champion – Zwingli Refused Leave to go to Baden – Martyrs – Arrival of the Deputies – Magnificent Dresses of the Romish Disputants – The Protestant Deputies – Personal Appearance of Eck and Ecolampadius – Points Debated – Eck Claims the Victory – The Protestants Gather the Fruits – Zwingli kept Informed of the Process of the Debate – Clever Device – A Comedy – Counsels Frustrated – Eck and Charles V. Helping the Reformation. |
| Chapter 3 | OUTBREAK AND SUPPRESSION OF ANABAPTISM IN SWITZERLAND. Rise of Anabaptism in Switzerland – Thomas Munzer – His First Disciples, Grebel and Manx – Summary of their Opinions – Their Manners and Morals – Zwingli Commanded to Dispute with them – Coercive Measures – Anabaptism extends to other Cantons – John Schuker and his Family – Horrible Tragedy – Manx – His Seditious Acts – Sentenced to be Drowned in the Lake of Zurich – Execution of Sentence - These Severities Disapproved of by Zwingli – The Fanaticism Extinguished by the Gospel, A Purification of the Swiss Church, Zwingli's Views on Baptism Matured thereby. |
| Chapter 4 | ESTABLISHMENT OF PROTESTANTISM AT BERN. Bern prepares to Follow up the Baden Disputation – Resolves to institute a Conference – Summoned for January, 1528 – Preparations and Invitations – The Popish Cantons Protest against holding the Conference – Charles V. Writes Forbidding it – Reply of the Bernese German Deputies – Journey of Swiss Deputies – Deputies in all 350 – Church of the Cordeliers – Ten Theses – Convert at the Altar – Fete of St. Vincent – Matins and Vespers Unsung – The Magnificat Exchanged for a Mourning Hymn – Clergy Subscribe the Reformed Propositions – Mass, etc., Abolished – Reforming Laws – Act of Civic Grace – The Lord's Supper. |
| Chapter 5 | REFORMATION CONSUMMATED IN BASLE. All Switzerland Moved – The Oberland – Surprise and Anger of its Herdsmen – Basle – Its Importance – Ecolampadius – Protestants of Basle Petition for Abolition of Mass – Popular Conflicts – Temporizing Policy of Council – Citizens take Arms – New Delays by the Council – New Demands of the People – The Night of the 8th of February – The City Barricaded – Two Thousand Men in Arms – The Senate's Half-concession – The Idols Broken – Idols of Little Basle – Edict of Senate Establishing the Reform – Ash-Wednesday – Oath of the People – Exodus of the Priests – Departure of Erasmus. |
| Chapter 6 | LEAGUE OF THE FIVE CANTONS WITH AUSTRIA — SWITZERLAND DIVIDED. The Light Spreading — The Oberland in Darkness — The Gospel Invades the Mountains — League of the Five Cantons with Austria — Persecution Begun — Martyrdom of Pastor Keyser — The Christian Coburghery — The Breach among the Swiss Cantons Widening — Dean Bullinger — The Men of Gaster — Idols that won't March — Violence of the Popish Cantons — Effort of Zurich to Avert War-The Attempt Abortive — War Proclaimed — Zwingli's Part in the Affair — Was it Justifiable? |
| Chapter 7 | ARMS — NEGOTIATIONS — PEACE. Zurich Girds on the Sword — Mustering in the Popish Cantons — 4,000 Warriors March from Zurich — Encamp at Kappel — Halt — Negotiations, Peace — Zwingli Dislikes it — Zwingli's Labors — His Daily Life — His Dress, etc., Arrangement of his Time, His Occupations — Amusements Writings. |
| Chapter 8 | PROPOSED CHRISTIAN REPUBLIC FOR DEFENCE OF CIVIL RIGHTS. Another Storm brewing in the Oberland — Protestantism still spreading in Switzerland — A Second Crisis — Zwingli proposes a European Christian Republic — Negotiates with the German Towns, the King of France, and the Republic of Venice — Philip of Hesse to be put at the Head of it — Correspondence between Philip and Zwingli — League for Defense of Civil Rights only — Zwingli's Labors for the Autonomy of the Helvetian Church. |
| Chapter 9 | GATHERING OF A SECOND STORM. Persecution renewed by the Five Cantons — Activity of Zwingli — Address of the Reformed Pastors - Bern proposes Blockade of the Five Cantons — Zwingli Opposed — No Bread, etc. — Zwingli asks his Dismissal - Consents to Remain — Meeting at Bremgarten — The Comet — Alarming Portents — Zwingli's Earnest Warnings-Unheeded. |
| Chapter 10 | DEATH OF ZWINGLI. Forest Cantons decide on War — Assembling of their Army — Zurich dispatches 600 Hen — Tedious Debates in the Council — A Night of Terror — Morning — The Great Banner Clings to its Staff — Depression — 700 mustered instead of 4,000 — Zwingli Mounts his Steed — Parting with his Wife and Children — Omens — The Battle — Bravery of the Zurichers — Overwhelmed by Numbers — The Carnage — Zwingli Mortally Wounded — Dispatched by Camp Followers — Tidings of his Death — Grief and Dismay |
FOLLOWING in the track of the light, we have reached our farthest limit toward
the north. We now turn southward to those lands where the Reformation had its first
rise, and where it fought its greatest battles. There every step it took was amidst
stakes and scaffolds, but if there its course was the more tragic, its influence
was the more powerful, and the changes it effected the more lasting. In France thousands
of confessors and martyrs are about to step upon the stage, and act their part in
the great drama; but first we must turn aside to Switzerland, and resuming our narrative
at the point where we dropped it, we shall carry it forward to the death of Zwingli.
We have traced in former pages the dawn of Protestantism among the hills of Helvetia.
Not from Germany, for the name of Luther had not yet been heard in Switzerland; not
from France, nor any neighboring country, but from the skies, it may be truly said,
the light first shone upon the Swiss. From a herdsman's cottage in the valley of
the Tockenburg came their Reformer, Ulric Zwingli. When a child he was wont to sit
by the evening's hearth and listen with rapt attention to the histories of the Bible
recited by his pious grandmother. As years passed on and his powers expanded he found
access to the book itself, and made it his daily study. The light broke upon his
soul. Continuing to read, it shone clearer every day. At last, but not fill years
after, his eyes were fully opened, he saw the glory of the Gospel, and bade a final
adieu to Rome.
Personal contact with evil can alone give that sense of its malignity, and that burning
detestation of it, which will prompt one to a life-long struggle for its overthrow.
We can trace this principle in the orderings of Zwingli's lot. He was destined to
spend his days in constant battle with two terrible evils that were tarnishing his
country's fame, and extinguishing his country's virtue. But reared in the Tockenburg,
artless and simple as its shepherds, he was not yet fit for his destined work, and
had to be sent to school. We refer to other schools than those of Basle and Vienna,
where he was initiated into the language and philosophy of the ancients. First stationed
at Glarus, he there was brought into contact with the horrors of the foreign service.
He had daily before his eyes the widows and orphans of the men who had been drawn
by French and Italian gold across the Alps and slaughtered; and there, too, he saw
a not less affecting sight, the maimed and emaciated forms of those who, escaping
the sword, had brought back to their country worse evils than wounds, even the vices
of corrupt and luxurious nations. At Einsiedeln, to which by-and-by he removed, he
received his second lesson. There he had occasion to mark the ravages which pilgrimages
and image-worship inflict upon the conscience and the morals. He had time to meditate
on these two great evils. He resolved to spare no effort to uproot them. But his
trust for success in this work was solely in the Gospel. This alone could dispel
the darkness in which pilgrimages with all their attendant abominations had their
rise, and this alone could extinguish that love of gold which was draining at once
the blood and the virtue of his countrymen. Other and subsidiary aids would come
in their time to assist in this great battle; but the Gospel must come first. He
would teach the individual Swiss to bow before a holy altar, and to sit at a pure
hearth; and this in due time would pour a current of fresh blood into the veins of
the State. Then the virtue of old days would revive, and their glorious valleys would
again be trodden by men capable of renewing the heroic deeds of their sires. But
the seed of Divine truth must be scattered over the worn-out soil before fruits like
these could flourish in it. These were the views that led to the striking union of
the pastor and the patriot which Zwingli presents to us. The aim of his Reform, wider
in its direct scope than that of Germany, embraced both Church and State, the latter
through the former. It was not because he trusted the Gospel less, but because he
trusted it more, and saw it to be the one fruitful source of all terrestrial virtues
and blessings, and because he more freely interpreted his mission as a Reformer,
and as a member of a republic felt himself more thoroughly identified with his country,
and more responsible for its failings, than it is possible for a subject of an empire
to do, that he chalked out for himself this course and pursued it so steadfastly.
He sought to restore to the individual piety, to the nation virtue, and both he would
derive from the same fountain – the Gospel.
Having seen and pondered over the two lessons put before him, Zwingli was now prepared
for his work. A vacancy occurred in the Cathedral-church of Zurich. The revival of
letters had reached that city, and the magistrates cast their eyes around them for
some one of greater accomplishments than the chapter could supply to fill the post.
Their choice fell on the Chaplain of Einsiedeln. Zwingli brought to Zurich a soul
enlightened by Divine truth, a genius which solitude had nursed into ardor and sublimity,
and a heart burning with indignation at the authors of his nation's ruin. He firmly
resolved to use his eloquence, which was great, in rousing his countrymen to a sense
of their degradation. He now stood at the center of the Republic, and his voice sounded
in thrilling tones through all Switzerland. He proceeded step by step, taking care
that his actual reforms did not outrun the stage of enlightenment his countrymen
had reached. He shone equally as a pastor as a writer and as a disputant. He was
alike at home in the council-chamber, in the public assembly, and in the hall of
business. His activity was untiring. His clear penetrating intellect and capacious
mind made toil light, and enabled him to accomplish the work of many men. The light
spread around him, other Reformers arose. It was now as when morning opens in that
same Swiss land: it is not Mont Blanc that stands up in solitary radiance; a dozen
and a dozen peaks around him begin to burn, and soon not a summit far or near but
is touched with glory, and not a valley, however profound, into which day does not
pour the tide of its effulgence. So did the sky of Switzerland begin to kindle all
round with the Protestant dawn. Towns and hamlets came out of the darkness – the
long and deep darkness of monkery – and stood forth in the light. The great centers,
Bern (1528), Basle (1529), Schaffhausen (1529), St. Call (1528), abandoned Rome and
embraced the Gospel. Along the foot of the Jura, around the shores of the lakes,
east and west of Northern Switzerland, from the gates of Geneva to the shores of
Constance did the light spread. The altars on which mass had been offered were overturned;
the idols burned like other wood; cowls, frocks, beads, and pardons were cast away
as so much rubbish; the lighted candles were blown out and men turned to the living
lamp of the Word. Its light led them to the cross whereon was offered, once for all,
the sacrifice of the Eternal Priest.
We halted in our narrative at what might be termed the noon of the Zwinglian Reformation.
We saw Protestantism fully established in Zurich, and partially in the cantons named
above; but the man who had had the honor to begin the work was not to have the honor
of completing it; his brilliant career was soon to close; already there were signs
of tempest upon the summit of the Helvetian mountains; by-and-by the storm will burst
and obscure for a time – not destroy the great work which the Reformer of Zurich
had originated. The catastrophe which is but a little way before us must be our second
stage in the Swiss Reformation.
The last time Zwingli came before us was at Marburg in 1529, where we find him maintaining
against Luther the spirituality of the ordinance of the Lord's Supper. Before resuming
our narrative of events it becomes necessary to explain the position of Zwingli,
with reference to the Sacrament of the Lord's Supper, and this requires us to consider
the views on this head held by Luther and Calvin. It is possible clearly to perceive
the precise doctrine of the Sacrament taught by any one of these great men only when
we have compared the views of all three.
The Lord's Supper began early to be corrupted in the primitive Church. The simple
memorial was changed into a mystery. That mystery became, century by century, more
awful and inexplicable. It was made to stand apart from other ordinances and services
of the Church, not only in respect of the greater reverence with which it was regarded,
but as an institution in its own nature wholly distinct, and altogether peculiar
in its mode of working. A secret virtue or potency was attributed to it, by which,
apart from the faith of the recipient, it operated mysteriously upon the soul. It
was no longer an ordinance, it was now a spell, a charm. The spirit of ancient paganism
had crept back into it, and ejecting the Holy Spirit, which acts through it in the
case of all who believe, it had filled it with a magical influence. The Lord's Supper
was the institution nearest the cross, and the spirit of reviving error in seizing
upon it was actuated doubtless by the consideration that the perversion of this institution
was the readiest and most effectual way to shut up or poison the fountain of the
world's salvation. The corruption went on till it issued, in 1215, in the dogma of
transubstantiation. The bread and wine which were set upon the Communion tables of
the first century became, by the fiat of Innocent III., flesh and blood on the altars
of the thirteenth.
Despite that the dogma of transubstantiation is opposed to Scripture, contradicts
reason, and outrages all our senses, there is about it, we are compelled to conclude,
some extraordinary power to hold captive the mind. Luther, who razed to the ground
every other part of the Romish system, left this one standing. He had not courage
to cast it down; he continued to his life's end to believe in consubstantiation –
that is, in the presence of the flesh and blood of Christ with, in, or under the
bread and wine. He strove, no doubt, to purify his belief from the gross materialism
of the Romish mass. He denied that the Lord's Supper was a sacrifice, or that the
body of Christ in the elements was to be worshipped; but he maintained that the body
was there, and was received by the communicant. The union of the Divinity with the
humanity in Christ's person gave to His glorified body, he held, new and wholly unearthly
qualities. It made it independent of space, it endowed it with ubiquity; and when
Zwingli, at Marburg, argued in reply that this was opposed to all the laws of matter,
which necessitated a body to be in only one place at one time, Luther scouted the
objection as being merely mathematical. The Reformer of Wittemberg did not seem to
perceive that fatal consequences would result in other directions, from asserting
such a change upon the body of Christ as he maintained to be wrought upon it in virtue
of its union with the Divinity, for undoubtedly such a theory imperils the reality
of the two great facts which are the foundations of the Christian system, the death
and the resurrection of our Lord.
Nor was it Luther only who did homage to this dogma. A yet more powerful intellect,
Calvin namely, was not able wholly to disenthrall himself from its influence, he
believed, it is true, neither in transubstantiation nor in consubstantiation, but
he hesitated to admit the thorough, pure spirituality of the Lord's Supper. He teaches
that the communicant receives Christ, who is spiritually present, only by his faith;
but he talks vaguely, withal, as if he conceived of an emanation or influence radiated
from the glorified humanity now at the Right hand, entering into the soul of the
believer, and implanting there the germ of a glorified humanity like to that of his
risen Lord. In this scarcely intelligible idea there may be more than the lingering
influence of the mysticism of bygone ages. We can trace in it a desire on the part
of Calvin to approximate as nearly as possible the standpoint of the Lutherans, if
so he might close the breach which divided and weakened the two great bodies of Protestants,
and rally into one host all the forces of the Reformation in the face of a yet powerful
Papacy.
Zwingli has more successfully extricated the spiritual from the mystical in the Sacrament
of the Lord's Supper than either Luther or Calvin. His sentiments were a recoil from
the mysticism and absurdity which, from an early age, had been gathering round this
Sacrament, and which had reached their height in the Popish doctrine of the mass.
Some have maintained that the recoil went too far, that Zwingli fell into the error
of excessive simplicity, and that he reduced the ordinance of the Lord's Supper to
a mere memorial or commemoration service. His earliest statements (1525) on the doctrine
of the Sacraments, and especially the Eucharist, may be open to this objection; but
not so his latter teachings (1530), we are disposed to think. He returned to the
golden mean, avoiding both extremes – neither attributing to the Sacrament a mystical
or magical efficacy, on the one hand, nor making it a bare and naked sign of a past
event on the other.
In order to understand his views, and see their accordance with Scripture, we must
attend a moment to the nature and design of the Lord's Supper as seen in its institution.
The primary end and significance of the Lord's Supper is a commemoration: "Do
this in remembrance of me." But the event commemorated is of such a kind, and
our relation to it is of such a nature, that the commemoration of it necessarily
implies more than mere remembrance. We are commemorating a "death" which
was endured in our room, and is all expiation of our sin; we, therefore, cannot commemorate
it to the end in view but in faith. We rest upon it as the ground of our eternal
life; we thus receive his "flesh and blood" – that is, the spiritual blessings
his death procured. Nay, more, by a public act we place ourselves in the ranks of
his followers. We promise or vow allegiance to him. This much, and no more, is done
on the human side.
We turn to the Divine side. What is signified and done here must also be modified
and determined by the nature of the transaction. The bread and wine in the Eucharist,
being the representatives of the body and blood of Christ, are the symbols of an
eternal redemption. In placing these symbols before us, and inviting us to partake
of them, God puts before us and offers unto us that redemption. We receive it by
faith, and he applies it to us and works it in us by his Spirit. Thus the Supper
becomes at once a sign and a seal. Like the "blood" on the door-post of
the Israelite, it is a "token" between God and us, for from the Passover
the Lord's Supper is historically descended, and the intent and efficacy of the former,
infinitely heightened, live in the latter. This, in our view, exhausts, both on the
Divine and on the human side, all which the principles of the Word of God warrant
us to hold in reference to the Eucharist; and if we attempt to put more into it,
that more, should we closely examine it, will be found to be not spiritual but magical.
Zwingli's grand maxim as a Reformer eminently was the authority of Holy Scripture.
Luther rejected nothing in the worship of God unless it was condemned in the Bible:
Zwingli admitted nothing unless it was enjoined. Following his maxim, Zwingli, forgetting
all human glosses, Papal edicts, and the mysticism of the schools, came straight
to the New Testament, directed his gaze steadfastly and exclusively upon its pages,
and gathered from thence what the Lord's Supper really meant. He found that on the
human side it was a "commemoration" and a "pledge," and on the
Divine side a "sign" and "seal." Further, the instrumentality
on the part of man by which he receives the blessing represented is faith; and the
agency on the part of God, by which that blessing is conveyed and applied, is the
Holy Spirit.
Such was the Lord's Supper as Ulric Zwingli found it in the original institution.
He purged it from every vestige of mysticism and materialism; but he left its spiritual
efficacy unimpaired and perfect.
CHAPTER 2 Back
to Top
DISPUTATION AT BADEN AND ITS RESULTS.
Alarm of the Romanists – Resolve to Strike a great Blow – They propose a Public Disputation
– Eck chosen as Romanist Champion – Zwingli Refused Leave to go to Baden – Martyrs
– Arrival of the Deputies – Magnificent Dresses of the Romish Disputants – The Protestant
Deputies – Personal Appearance of Eck and Ecolampadius – Points Debated – Eck Claims
the Victory – The Protestants Gather the Fruits – Zwingli kept Informed of the Process
of the Debate – Clever Device – A Comedy – Counsels Frustrated – Eck and Charles
V. Helping the Reformation.
THE victories that we narrated in a foregoing Book of this History (Book 8.) caused
the utmost alarm among the partisans of the Papacy. The movement, first despised
by them, and next half welcomed as holding out the hope of a little pleasurable excitement,
had now grown to such a head that it threatened to lay in the dust the whole stately
fabric of their riches and power. They must go wisely to work, and strike such a
blow as would sweep Zwingli and his movement from the soil of Helvetia. This, said
they, making sure of their victory before winning it, will react favorably on Germany.
The torrent once stemmed, the waters of heresy will retreat to the abyss whence they
issued, and the "everlasting hills" of the old faith, which the deluge
threatened to overtop, will once more lift up their heads stable and majestic as
ever.
An event that happened in the political world helped yet further to impress upon
the Romanists the necessity of some instant and vigorous step. The terrible battle
of Pavia projected a dark shadow upon Switzerland, but shed a gleam of popularity
on Zwingli, and indirectly on the Reformation. A numerous body of Swiss mercenaries
had fought on that bloody field. From five to six thousand of their corpses swelled
its slain, and five thousand were taken alive and made prisoners. These were afterwards
released and sent home, but in what a plight! Their arms lopped off, their faces
seamed and scarred; many, through hunger and faintness, dying by the way, and the
rest arriving in rags! Not only was it that these spectacles of horror wandered over
the land, but from every city and hamlet arose the wail of widow and the cry of orphan.
What the poet said of Albion might now be applied to Helvetia:
In that day of their sore calamity the people remembered how often Zwingli had
thundered against the foreign service from the pulpit. He had been, they now saw,
their best friend, their truest patriot; and the Popish cantons envied Zurich, which
mainly through Zwingli's influence had wholly escaped, or suffered but slightly,
from a stroke which had fallen with such stunning force upon themselves.
The Romanists saw the favorable impression that was being made upon the popular sentiment,
and bethought them by what means they might counteract it. The wiser among them reflected,
on the one hand, how little progress they were making in the suppression of Lutheranism
by beheading and burning its disciples; and, on the other, how much advantage Zwingli
had gained from the religious disputation at Zurich. "They deliberated,"
says Bullinger, "day and night," and at last came to the conclusion that
the right course was to hold a public disputation, and conquer the Reformation by
its own weapons – leaving its truth out of their calculations. They would so arrange
beforehand as to make sure of the victory, by selecting the fitting place at which
to hold the disputation, and the right men to decide between the controversialists.
The scheme promised to be attended with yet another advantage, although they took
care to say nothing about it, unless to those they could absolutely trust. Zwingli,
of course, would come to the conference. He would be in their power. They could condemn
and burn him, and the death of its champion would be the death of the movement.[2]
Accordingly at a Diet held at Lucerne, the 15th January, 1526, the Five Cantons
– Lucerne, Uri, Schwitz, Appenzell, and Friburg – resolved on a disputation, and
agreed that it should take place at Bern. The Bernese, however, declined the honor.
Basle was then selected as the next most suitable, being a university seat, and boasting
the residence within it of many learned men. But Basle was as little covetous of
the honor as Bern.
After a good deal of negotiating, it was concluded to hold the disputation at Baden
on the 16th May, 1526.[3]
This being settled, the cantons looked around them for powerful champions
to do battle for the old faith. One illustrious champion, who had figured not without
glory on the early fields of the Reformation, still survived Dr. Eck, Vice-Chancellor
of Ingolstadt. Our readers have not forgotten the day of Leipsic, where Eck encountered
Luther, and foiled him, as he boasted; but finding Luther perversely blind to his
defeat, he went to Rome, and returned with the bull of Leo X. to burn the man who
had no right to live after having been confuted by Eck. Dr. Eck was a man of undoubted
learning, of unrivalled volubility – in short, the best swordsman Rome had then at
her service. The choice of the Popish cantons unanimously fell on this veteran.
Eck was to reap from this passage-at-arms more solid laurels than mere fame. On the
side of Rome the battle had begun to be maintained largely by money. The higher clergy
in Suabia and Switzerland piously taxed themselves for this laudable object. The
Suabian League and the Archduke of Austria raised money to hire the services of men
willing and able to fight in these campaigns. There was no reason why the doctor
of Ingolstadt should give his time, and endanger, if not life, yet those hard-won
honors that made life sweet, without a reasonable recompense. Eck was to be handsomely
paid;[4] for, says Bullinger, quoting a very old precedent, "he
loved the wages of unrighteousness." The doctor of Ingolstadt accepted the combat,
and with it victory, its inseparable consequence as he deemed it. Writing to the
Confederate deputies at Baden, Dr. Eck says, "I am full of confidence that I
shall, with little trouble, maintain against Zwingli our old true Christian faith
and customs to be accordant with Holy Scripture," and then with a scorn justifiable,
it may be, in so great a personage as the Vice-Chancellor of the University of Ingolstadt,
when descending into the arena to meet the son of the shepherd of the Tockenburg,
he says, "Zwingli no doubt has milked more cows than he has read books."[5]
But Dr. Eck was not to encounter Zwingli at Baden. The Council of Zurich refused
leave to their pastor to go to the conference. Whispers had come to the ears of their
Excellencies that the Romanists intended to employ other weapons besides argument.
The place where the conference was to be held was of evil omen; for at Baden the
blood of the Wirths [6] was yet scarcely dry; and there the Popish cantons were all-powerful.
Even Eck, with whom Zwingli was to dispute, had proclaimed the futility of fighting
against such heretics as the preacher of Zurich with any other weapons than "fire
and sword."[7] So far as the "fire" could reach him it had already
been employed against Zwingli; for they had burned his books at Friburg and his effigy
at Lucerne. He was ready to meet at Zurich their entire controversial phalanx from
its Goliath downwards, and the magistrates would have welcomed such meeting; but
send him to Baden the council would not, for that was to send him not to dispute,
but to die.
In coming to this conclusion the lords of Zurich transgressed no law of charity,
and their conclusion, hard though it was, did the Romanists of Switzerland no wrong.
Wherever at this hour they looked in the surrounding cantons and provinces, what
did they see? Stakes and victims. The men who were so eager to argue at Baden showed
no relish for so tedious a process where they could employ the more summary one of
the sack and rope. At Lucerne, Henry Messberg was thrown into the lake for speaking
against the nuns; and John Nagel was burned alive for sowing "Zwinglian tenets."
At Schwitz, Eberhard Polt of Lachen, and a priest of the same place, suffered death
by burning for speaking against the ceremonies. At the same time Peter Spongier,
a Protestant minister, was drowned at Friburg by order of the Bishop of Constance.
Nor did the man who had won so many laurels in debate, disdain adding thereto the
honors of the executioner. But a short week before the conference at Baden, Eck presided
over a consistory which met in the market-place of Mersburg, and condemned to the
flames as a heretic John Hugel, the Pastor of Lindau. The martyr went to the stake
singing the Te Deum, and was heard amid the fires offering the prayer, "Father,
forgive them."[8]
When the appointed day came the deputies began to arrive. Twelve cantons of
the Confederacy sent each a representative. Zurich had received no invitation and
sent no deputy. The Bishops of Constance, of Coire, of Lausanne, and of Basle were
also represented at the conference. Eck came attended by Faber, the college companion
of Zwingli,[9] and Thomas Murner, a monk of the order of the Carmelites.
The list of Protestant controversialists was a modest one, embracing only the names
of Ecolampadius from Basle, and Haller from Bern. In neither of these two cities
was the Reformation as yet (1526) established, but the conference just opening was
destined to give a powerful impulse to Protestantism in both of them. In Bern and
Basle it halted meanwhile; but from this day the Reformation was to resume its march
in these cities, and pause only when it had reached the goal. Could the Romanists
have foreseen this result, they would have been a little less zealous in the affair
of the conference. If the arguments of the Popish deputies should prove as strong
as their dresses were magnificent, there could be no question with whom would remain
the victory. Eck and his following of prelates, magistrates, and doctors came robed
in garments of damask and silk. They wore gold chains round their necks; crosses
reposed softly and piously on their breasts; their fingers glittered and burned with
precious jewels;[10] and their measured step and uplifted countenances were such
as beseemed the bravery of their apparel. If the plays of our great dramatist had
been then in existence, and if the men now assembling at Baden had been a troupe
of tragedians, who had been hired to act them, nothing could have been in better
taste; but fine robes were slender qualifications for a discussion which had for
its object the selection and adoption of those principles on which the Churches and
kingdoms of the future were to be constructed. In the eyes of the populace, the Reformers,
in comparison with the men in damask, were but as a company of mendicants. The two
were not more different in dress than in their way of living. Eck and his friends
lodged at the Baden parsonage, where the wine, provided by the Abbot of Wettingen,
was excellent. It was supplied without stint, and used not less so.[11] Ecolampadius
put up at the Pike Inn. His meals were quickly dispatched, and the landlord, wondering
how he occupied his time in his room, peered in, and found him reading or praying.
"A heretic, doubtless," said he, "but a pious one withal."
Eck was still the same man we saw him at Leipsic – his shoulders as broad, his voice
as Stentorian, and his manner as violent. If the logic of his argument halted, he
helped it with a vigorous stamp of his foot, and, as a contemporary poet of Bern
relates, an occasional oath. In striking contrast to his porter-like figure, was
the tall, thin, dignified form of his opponent Ecolampadius. Some of the Roman Catholics,
says Bullinger, could not help wishing that the "sallow man," so calm,
yet so firm and so majestic, were on "their side."
It is unnecessary to give any outline of the disputation. The ground traversed was
the same which had been repeatedly gone over. The points debated were those of the
real presence, the sacrifice of the mass, the adoration of Mary and the saints, worshipping
by images, and purgatory, with a few minor questions.[12] The contest
lasted eighteen days. "Every day the clergy of Baden," says Ruchat, "walked
in solemn procession, and chanted litanies, to have good success in the disputation."[13] Eck reveled in the combat, and when it had ended he claimed
the victory, and took care to have the great news published through the Confederacy,
exciting in the Popish cantons the lively hope of the instant restoration of the
old faith to its former glory. But the question is, who gathered the spoils? We can
have no difficulty in answering that question when we think of the fresh life imparted
to Bern and Basle, and the rapid strides with which, from this time forward, they
and other cities advanced to the establishment of their Reformation.
Eck felt the weight of Zwingli's arm, although the Reformer was not present in person.
The Popish party, having appointed four secretaries to make a faithful record of
the conference, prohibited all others from taking notes of the debate, under no less
a penalty than death. Yet, despite this stern law, evening by evening Zwingli was
told how the fight had gone, and was able, morning by morning, to send his advice
to his friends how to set the battle in order for the day. It was cleverly done.
A student from the Vallais, Jerome Walsch, who professed to be using the baths of
Baden, attended the conference, and every evening wrote down from memory the course
the argument had taken that day. Two students did the office of messenger by turns.
Arriving at Zurich overnight, they handed Walsch's notes, together with the letters
of Ecolampadius, to Zwingli, and were back at Baden next morning with the Reformer's
answer. To lull the suspicions of the armed sentries at the gates, who had been ordered
to keep a strict watch, they carried on their heads baskets of poultry. Even theologians,
they hinted, must eat. If Dr. Eck, and the worthy divines with him, should go without
their dinner, they would not be answerable for what might happen to the good cause
of Romanism, or to those who should take it upon them to stop the supplies. Thus
they came and went without its being suspected on what errand they journeyed.
After the serious business of the conference, there came a little comedy. In the
train of the doctor of Ingolstadt, as we have already said, came Thomas Murner, monk
and lecturer at Lucerne. The deputies of the cantons had just given judgment for
Eck, to the effect that he had triumphed in the debate, and crushed the Zwinglian
heresy. But Murner, aspiring to the honor of slaying the slain, rose, in presence
of the whole assembly, and read forty charges, which, putting body and goods in pledge,
he offered to make good against Zwingli. No one thought it worth while to reply.
Whereupon the Cordelier continued, "I thought the coward would crone, but he
has not shown face. I declare forty times, by every law human and divine, that the
tyrant of Zurich and all his followers are knaves, liars, perjurers, adulterers,
infidels, thieves, sacrileges, gaol-birds, and such that no honest man without blushing
can keep company with them."[14] Having so spoken he sat down, and the Diet was at an end.
Thus we behold, at nearly the same moment, on two stages widely apart, measures taken
to suppress Protestantism, which, in their results, help above all things to establish
it. In the little town of Baden we see the deputies of the cantons and the representatives
of the bishops assembling to confute the Zwinglians, and vote the extinction of the
Reform movement in Switzerland. Far away beyond the Pyrenees we see (March, 1526)
the Emperor Charles sitting down in the Moorish Alcazar at Seville, and indicting
a letter to his brother Archduke Ferdinand, commanding him to summon a Diet at Siftres,
to execute the Edict of Worms. The disputation at Baden led very directly, as we
shall immediately see, to the establishment of Protestantism in the two important
cantons of Bern and Basic. And the Diet of Spires (1526), instead of an edict of
proscription, produced, as we have already seen an edict of toleration in favor of
the Reformation. The Chancellor of the University of Ingolstadt and the head of the
Holy Roman Empire, acting without concert, and certainly not designing what they
accomplish, unite their powerful aids in helping onward the cause of the world's
emancipation. There is One who overrules their counsels, and makes use of them to
overthrow that which they wish to uphold, and protect that which they seek to destroy.
CHAPTER 3 Back
to Top
OUTBREAK AND SUPPRESSION OF ANABAPTISM IN SWITZERLAND.
Rise of Anabaptism in Switzerland – Thomas Munzer – His First Disciples, Grebel and
Manx – Summary of their Opinions – Their Manners and Morals – Zwingli Commanded to
Dispute with them – Coercive Measures – Anabaptism extends to other Cantons – John
Schuker and his Family – Horrible Tragedy – Manx – His Seditious Acts – Sentenced
to be Drowned in the Lake of Zurich – Execution of Sentence – These Severities Disapproved
of by Zwingli – The Fanaticism Extinguished by the Gospel – A Purification of the
Swiss Church – Zwingli's Views on Baptism Matured thereby.
THE river of Reform was rolling its bounteous floods onward and diffusing verdure
over the barren lands, when suddenly a foul and poisoned rivulet sought to discharge
itself into it. Had this latter corrupted the great stream with which it seemed on
the point of mingling, death and not life would have been imparted to the nations
of Christendom. Zwingli foresaw the evil, and his next labor was to prevent so terrible
a disaster befalling the world; and his efforts in this important matter claim our
attention before proceeding to trace the influence of the Baden disputation on the
two powerful cantons of Bern and Basle.
Zwingli was busy, as we have seen, combating the Papal foe in front, when the Anabaptist
enemy suddenly started up and attacked him in the rear. We have already detailed
the deplorable tragedies to which this fanatical sect gave birth in Germany.[1] They were about
to vent the same impieties and enact the same abominable excesses on the soil of
Switzerland which had created so much misery elsewhere. This sect was rather an importation
than a native growth of Helvetia. The notorious Thomas Munzer, thrown upon the Swiss
frontier by the storms of the peasant-war in Germany, brought with him his peculiar
doctrines to sow them among the followers of Zwingli. He found a few unstable minds
prepared to receive them, in particular Conrad Grebel, of an ancient Swiss family,
and Felix Manx, the son of a prebend. These two were Munzer's first disciples, and
afterwards leaders of the sect. They had been excellently educated, but were men
of loose principles and licentious lives. To these persons others by-and-by joined
themselves.[2]
These men came to Zwingli and said to him, "Let us found a Church in
which there shall be no sin." Grebel and Manx had a way peculiar to themselves
of forming an immaculate society. Their method, less rare than it looks, was simply
to change all the vices into virtues, and thus indulgence in them would imply no
guilt and leave no stain. This was a method of attaining sinlessness in which Zwingli
could not concur, being unable to reconcile it with the Gospel precept which says
that "denying ungodliness and worldly lusts, we should live soberly, righteously,
and godly in the present evil world." "In whatever crime or vice they are
taken," said Zwingli, "their defense is ever the same: I have not sinned;
I am no more in the flesh, but in the spirit; I am dead to the flesh, and the flesh
is dead to me." The wisdom of Zwingli's reply to Grebel's proposal was as great
as its words were few. "We cannot," said he, "make a heaven upon earth."[3]
Re baptism was rather the badge than the creed of this sect. Under the spiritual
pretext of emancipation from the flesh, they denied the office and declined the authority
of the pastors of the Church and of the magistrates of the State.[4] Under the same
pretext of spirituality they claimed a release from every personal virtue and all
social obligations. They dealt in the same way with the Bible. They had a light within
which sufficed for their guidance, and made them independent of the Word without.
Some of them threw the book into the fire saying, "The letter killeth."
"Infant baptism," said they, "is a horrible abomination, a flagrant
impiety, invented by the evil spirit and Pope Nicholas of Rome."[5]
The freaks and excesses in which they began to indulge were very extraordinary,
and resembled those of men whose wits are disordered. They would form themselves
in a ring on the street, dance, sing songs, and tumble each other about in the dust.
At other times, putting on sackcloth, and strewing ashes on their heads, they would
rush through the streets, bearing lighted torches, and uttering dismal cries, "Woe!
woe! yet forty days and Zurich shall be destroyed."[6] Others professed
to have received revelations from the Holy Spirit. Others interrupted the public
worship by standing up in the midst of the congregation and proclaiming aloud, "I
am the door; by me, if any man enter in, he shall be saved." They held from
time to time nocturnal revels, at which psalms and jovial ballads were sung alternately,
and this they called "setting up the Lord's table."
Fourteen of their number were apprehended by the magistrates, contrary to Zwingli's
advice, shut up in the Heretics' Tower, and fed on bread and water. On the fourteenth
day "an angel opened their prison door and led them forth."[7] Contrary to what
happened in Peter's case, with which they compared their deliverance, the angel found
it necessary to remove certain planks before he could effect their liberation.
The magistrates, alarmed for the public peace, ordered Zwingli to hold a disputation
with them. The conference took place on the 17th January, 1525. Zwingli's victory
was complete, and the magistrates followed it up by an edict, ordering all infants
to be baptized within eight days.[8] The fanatics no more gave obedience to the command of the
magistrates than submission to the arguments of Zwingli. They neither brought their
children to be baptized nor abjured their opinions. A second disputation, was enjoined
by the council. It was held in the March of the same year, but with the same results.
Victory or defeat came alike to men who had resolved to adhere to their beliefs whatever
arguments might be brought in refutation of them.
Severer measures were now adopted against them. Some were imprisoned; others were
banished from the canton. Zwingli disapproved of these coercive remedies, and the
event justified his wisdom. Persecution but inflamed their zeal, and their dispersion
carried the fire to other cantons. In St. Gall their numbers were reckoned at 800;
in the canton of Appenzell at 1,200. They extended also to Schaffhausen and the Grisons,
where they gave rise to disorders. Two of the sect undertook to go and preach in
the Popish canton of Schwitz; the unhappy creatures were seized and burned. They
died calling on the name of the Savior.[9]
In some cases fanaticism developed into madness; and that madness gave birth to atrocious
deeds which did more to open the eyes of the people, and banish this sect from the
soil of Switzerland, than all the punishments with which the magistrates pursued
it. One melancholy and most revolting instance has come down to us. In a solitary
house in the canton of St. Gall there lived an aged farmer, John Schuker, who, with
his family and servants, had received the "new baptism." Two of his sons
were specially noted for the warmth of their zeal. On Shrove Tuesday the father killed
a calf and invited his Anabaptist friends to the feast. The company, the wine, the
fanatical harangues and visionary revelations in which the night was spent, would
seem to have upset the reason of one of the sons. His features haggard, his eyes
rolling wildly, and speaking with hollow voice, he approached his brother, Leonard,
with the gall of the calf in the bladder, and thus addressed him, "Bitter as
gall is the death thou shalt die." He then ordered him to kneel down. Leonard
obeyed. A presentiment of evil seized the company. They bade the wretched man beware
what he did. "Nothing will happen," he replied, "but the will of the
Father." Turning to his brother, who was still kneeling before him, and hastily
seizing a sword, he severed his head from his body at a single blow. The spectators
were horror-struck. The headless corpse and the blood-stained maniac were terrible
sights. They had witnessed a crime like that of Cain. Groans and wailings succeeded
to the fanatical orisons in which the night had been spent. Quickly over the country
flew the news of the awful deed. The wretched fratricide escaping from the house,
half naked, the reeking sword in his hand, and posting with rapid steps through hamlet
and village to St. Gall, to proclaim with maniac gestures and frenzied voice "the
day of the Lord," exhibited in his own person an awful example of the baleful
issues in which the Anabaptist enthusiasm was finding its consummation. It was now
showing itself to men with the brand of Cain on its brow. The miserable man was seized
and beheaded.[10]
This horrible occurrence was followed by a tragedy nearly as horrible. We
have mentioned above the name of Manx, one of the leaders of the fanatics. This man
the magistrates of Zurich sentenced to be drowned in the lake. In adjudging him to
this fate they took account, not of his views on baptism, or any opinions strictly
religious, but of his sentiments on civil government. Not only did he deny the authority
of magistracy, but he gave practical effect to his tenets by teaching his followers
to resist payment of legal dues, and by instigating them to acts of outrage and violence,
he had been repeatedly imprisoned, but always returned to his former courses on being
set at liberty. The popular indignation against the sect, intensified by the deed
we have just narrated, and the danger in which Switzerland now stood, of becoming
the theater of the same bloody tragedies which had been enacted in Germany the year
before, would no longer permit the council to wink at the treasonable acts of Manx.
He was again apprehended, and this time his imprisonment was followed by his condemnation.
The sentence was carried out with due formality. He was accompanied to the water's
edge by his brother and mother, now an old woman, and the unacknowledged wife of
the prebend. They exhorted him to constancy, but indeed he exhibited no signs of
shrinking. They saw the executioner lead him into the boat; they saw him rowed out
to deep water; they saw him taken up and flung into the lake; they heard the sullen
plunge and saw the water close over him. The brother burst into tears, but the mother
stood and witnessed all with dry eyes.[11]
In these proceedings Zwingli had no share. This fanatical outburst had affected
him with profound sorrow. He knew it would be said, "See what bitter fruits
grow on the tree of Reform." But not only did he regard the reproach as unjust,
he looked to the Gospel as the only instrumentality able to cope with this fanaticism.
He pleaded with the magistrates to withhold their punishments, on the ground that
the weapons of light were all that were needed to extirpate the evil. These Zwingli
plied vigorously.
The battle against Anabaptism cost him "more sweat," to use his own expression,
than did his fight with the Papacy. But that sweat was not in vain. Mainly through
his labors the torrent of Anabaptist fanaticism was arrested, and what threatened
fatal disaster at the outset was converted into a blessing both to Zwingli and to
the Protestant Church of Switzerland. The latter emerged from the tempest purified
and strengthened. Instead of an accusation the Anabaptist outbreak was a justification
of the Reformation. Zwingli's own views were deepened and purified by the controversy.
He had been compelled to study the relation in which the Old and New Testaments stand
to one another, and he came to see that under two names they are one book, that under
two forms they are one revelation; and that as the transplanting of trees from the
nursery to the open field neither alters their nature nor changes their uses, so
the transplanting of the institutions of Divine revelation from the Old Testament,
in the soil of which they were first set, into the New Testament or Gospel dispensation
where they are permanently to flourish, has not in the least changed their nature
and design, but has left them identically the same institutions: they embody the
same principles and subserve the same ends. Baptism, he argued in short, is circumcision,
and circumcision was baptism, under a different outward form.
Proceeding on this principle, the sum of what he maintained in all his disputations
with the Anabaptists, and in all that he published from the press and the pulpit,
was that inasmuch as circumcision was administered to infants under the Old Testament,
it is clear that they were regarded as being, by their birth, members of the Church,
and so entitled to the seal of the covenant. In like manner the children of professing
parents under the New Testament are, by their birth, members of the Church, and entitled
to have the Sacrament of baptism administered to them: that the water in baptism,
like the blood in circumcision, denotes the removal of an inward impurity and the
washing by the Spirit in order to salvation; and that as circumcision bound to the
observance of God's ordinances, so baptism imposes an obligation to a holy life.[12]
CHAPTER 4 Back
to Top
ESTABLISHMENT OF PROTESTANTISM AT BERN.
Bern prepares to Follow up the Baden Disputation – Resolves to institute a Conference
– Summoned for January, 1528 – Preparations and Invitations – The Popish Cantons
Protest against holding the Conference – Charles V. Writes Forbidding it – Reply
of the Bernese German Deputies – Journey of Swiss Deputies – Deputies in all 350
– Church of the Cordeliers – Ten Theses – Convert at the Altar – Fete of St. Vincent
– Matins and Vespers Unsung – The Magnificat Exchanged for a Mourning Hymn – Clergy
Subscribe the Reformed Propositions – Mass, etc., Abolished – Reforming Laws – Act
of Civic Grace – The Lord's Supper.
THE disputation at Baden had ended in the way we have already described. The champions
engaged in it had returned to their homes. Eck, as his manner was, went back singing
his own praises and loudly vaunting the great victory he had won. Ecolampadius had
returned to Basle, and Haller to Bern, not at all displeased with the issue of the
affair, though they said little. While the Romanist champions were filling Switzerland
with their boastings, the Protestants quietly prepared to gather in the fruits.
The pastors, who from various parts of Switzerland had been present at the disputation,
returned home, their courage greatly increased. Moreover, on arriving in their several
spheres of labor they found a fresh interest awakened in the cause. The disputation
had quickened the movement it was meant to crush. They must follow up their success
before the minds of men had time to cool down. This was the purpose now entertained
especially by Bern, the proudest and most powerful member of the Swiss Confederacy.
Bern had been halting for some time between two opinions. Ever as it took a few paces
forward on the road of Reform, it would stop, turn round, and cast lingering and
regretful looks toward Rome. But now it resolved it would make its choice once for
all between the Pope and Luther, between the mass and the Protestant sermon. In November,
1527, it summoned a Diet to debate the question. "Unhappy Helvetia," said
some, "thus torn by religious opinions and conflicts. Alas! the hour when Zwingli
introduced these new doctrines." But was the, state of Switzerland so very sad
that it might justly envy the condition of other countries? As the Swiss looked from
his mountains he beheld the sky of Europe darkened with war-clouds all round. A fierce
tempest had just laid the glory of Rome in the dust. Francis I. and Henry of England,
with Milan, Venice, and Florence, were leaguing against the emperor. Charles was
unsheathing his sword to spill more blood while that of recent battles was scarcely
dry.
The deep scars of internecine conflict and hate were yet fresh on the soil of Germany.
Ferdinand of Austria was claiming the crowns of Bohemia and Hungary, and fighting
to rescue the provinces and inhabitants of Eastern Europe from the bloody scimitar
of the Turk. Such was the state of Europe when the lords and citizens of Bern assembled
in their Great Council on the Sabbath after Martinmas, 1527, resolved to institute
in the beginning of the coming year a conference on religion, after the model of
Zurich, to the intent "that the truth might not be concealed, but that the ground
of Divine truth, of Christian intelligence, and of saving health might be discovered,
and that a worship in conformity with the Holy Scriptures might be planted and observed."[1]
The preparations were on a scale commensurate with the rank of the city and
the gravity of the affair. Invitations were sent to the four Bishops of Lausanne,
Basle, Constance, and Sion, who were asked to be present either in person or by deputy,
under penalty of the loss of all rights and revenues which they claimed within the
canton of Bern in virtue of their episcopal dignity.
The Bernese sent to all the cantons and free towns of the Helvetic Confederacy, desiring
them to send their theologians and learned men of both parties to the conference,
to the end that, freely and without compulsion to any one, their common Confederacy
might make profession of a common faith. They further ordered that all the pastors
and cures in the canton should repair to Bern on the first Sunday of January, and
assist at the conference from its opening to its close, under pain of deprivation
of their benefices. Addressing the learned men of the State, "Come," said
the lords of Bern, "we undertake for your safety, and guarantee you all liberty
in the expression of your opinions."
One man was honored with a special invitation, Thomas Murner namely, who, as our
readers may recollect, gave so comic a close to the conference at Baden. His pleasantries
threatened to become serious things indeed to the Swiss. He was daily scattering
among the cantons the most virulent invectives against the Zwinglians, couched in
brutal language, fitted only to kindle the fiercest passions and plunge the Confederacy
into war. Their Excellencies did well in giving the Cordelier an opportunity of proving
his charges in presence of the conference. Murner did not come himself, but took
care to send a violent philippic against the Bernese.[2]
The adherents of the old faith, with one accord, entered their protest against
the holding of such a conference. They claimed to have won the victory at Baden,
but it would seem they wished no more such victories. The four bishops came first
with a strong remonstrance. The seven Popish cantons followed suit, conjuring the
Bernese to desist from a project that was full of danger, and abide by a Church in
which their fathers had been content to live and die: even the Emperor Charles wrote
exhorting them to abandon their design and await the assembling of a General Council.
"The settlement of the religious question," he added, "does not pertain
to any one city or country, but to all Christians " [3] – that is, practically
to himself and the Pope. There could not possibly be stronger proofs of the importance
the Romanists attached to the proposed conference, and the decisive influence it
was likely to exert on the whole of Switzerland. The reply of the Bernese was calm
and dignified. "We change nothing in the twelve articles of the Christian faith;
we separate not from the Church whose head is Christ; what is founded on the Word
of God will abide for ever; we shall only not depart from the Word of God."[4]
All eyes were turned on Zwingli. From far and near clergy and learned men
would be there, but Zwingli must take command of the army, he must be the Achilles
of the fight. The youthful Haller and the grey-headed Kolb had done battle alone
in Bern until now, but the action about to open required a surer eye and a sturdier
arm. Haller wrote in pressing terms to this "best-beloved brother and champion
in the cause of Christ," that he would be pleased to come. "You know,"
he said, "how much is here at stake, what shame, mockery, and disgrace would
fall upon the Evangel and upon us if we were found not to be competent to the task.
My brother, fail not."[5]
To this grand conference there came deputies not from Switzerland only, but
from many of the neighboring countries. On New Year's Eve, 1528, more than a hundred
clergy and learned men assembled at Zurich from Suabia, invitations having been sent
to the towns of Southern Germany.[6] The doctors of St. Gall, Schaffhausen, Glarus, Constance,
Ulm, Lindau, Augsburg, and other places also repaired to the rendezvous at Zurich.
On the following morning they all set out for Bern, and with them journeyed the deputies
from Zurich – Zwingli, Burgomaster Roist, Conrad Pellican,[7] Sebastien Hoffmeister,
Gaspard Grossmann, a great number of the rural clergy, Conrad Schmidt, Commander
of Kussnacht; Pierre Simmler, Prior of Kappel; and Henry Bullinger, Regent in the
college, of the same place.[8]
At the head of the cavalcade rode the Burgomaster of Zurich, Roist. By his
side were Zwingli and several of the councilors, also on horseback. The rest of the
deputies followed. A little in advance of the company rode the town herald, but without
his trumpet, for they wished to pass on without noise. The territory to be traversed
on the way to Bern was owned by the Popish cantons. The deputies had asked a safe-conduct,
but were refused. "There will be abundance of excellent game abroad," was
the news bruited through Popish Switzerland; "let us go a-hunting." If
they seriously meant what they said, their sport was spoiled by the armed escort
that accompanied the travelers. Three hundred men with arquebuss on shoulder marched
right and left of them.[9] In this fashion they moved onwards to Bern, to take captive
to Christ a proud city which no enemy had been able to storm. They entered its gates
on the 4th of January, and found already arrived there numerous deputies, among others
Ecolampadius of Basle, and Bucer and Capito of Strasburg.
The Bernese were anxious above all things to have the question between the two Churches
thoroughly sifted. For this end they invited the ablest champions on both sides,
guaranteeing them all freedom of debate. They heard of a worthy Cordelier at Grandson,
named De Marie Palud, a learned man, but too poor to be able to leave home. The lords
of Bern dispatched a special messenger with a letter to this worthy monk, earnestly
urging him to come to the conference, and bidding the courier protect his person
and defray his expenses on the road.[10] If Eck and the other great champions of Rome were absent,
it was because they chose not to come. The doctor of Ingolstadt would not sit in
an assembly of heretics where no proof, unless drawn from the Word of God, would
be received, nor any explanation of it admitted unless it came from the same source.
Did any one ever hear anything so unreasonable? asked Eck. Has the Bible a tongue
to refute those who oppose it? The roll-call showed a great many absentees besides
Eck. The names of the Bishops of Basle, Sion, Constance, and Lausanne were shouted
out in accents that rung through the church, but the echoes of the secretary's voice
were the only answer returned. The assemblage amounted to 350 persons – priests,
pastors, scholars, and councilors from Switzerland and Germany.
The Church of the Cordeliers was selected as the place of conference. A large platform
had been erected, and two tables placed on it. At the one table sat the Popish deputies,
round the other were gathered the Protestant disputants. Between the two sat four
secretaries, from whom a solemn declaration, tantamount to an oath, had been exacted,
that they would make a faithful record of all that was said and done. Four presidents
were chosen to rule in the debate.[11]
The disputation lasted twenty consecutive days, with the single interruption
of one day, the fete of St. Vincent, the patron saint of Bern. It commenced on the
6th January, and closed on the 27th. On Sunday as on other days did the conference
assemble. Each day two sessions were held – one in the morning, the other after dinner;
and each was opened with prayer.[12]
Ten propositions [13] a were put down to be debated. They were declarations of
the Protestant doctrine, drawn so as to comprehend all the points in controversy
between the two Churches. The discussion on the mass occupied two whole days, and
was signalized at its close by a dramatic incident which powerfully demonstrated
where the victory lay.
From the Church of the Cordeliers, Zwingli passed to the cathedral, to proclaim from
its pulpit, in the hearing of the people, the proofs he had maintained triumphantly
in the debate. At one of the side altars stood a priest, arrayed in pall and chasuble
and all necessary sacerdotal vestments for saying mass. He was just about to begin
the service when Zwingli's voice struck upon his car. He paused to listen. "He
ascended into heaven," said the Reformer in a slow and solemn voice, reciting
the creed; "and sitteth at the right hand of God the Father Almighty,"
pausing again; "from thence he shall come to judge the quick and the dead."
"These three articles," said Zwingli, "cannot stand with the mass."
The words flashed conviction into the mind of the priest. His resolution was taken
on the spot. Stripping off his priestly robes and flinging them on the altar, he
turned his eyes in the direction of Zwingli, and said in the hearing of all in the
cathedral, "If the mass rest on no better foundation, I will neither read it
now, nor read it more."[14] This victory at the very foot of the altar was hailed as
an omen of a full triumph at no great distance.
Three days thereafter was the fete of St. Vincent. The canons of the college waited
on the magistrates to know the pleasure of their Excellencies respecting its celebration.
They had been wont to observe the day with great solemnity in Bern. "Those of
you," said the magistrates to the canons, "who can subscribe the ten Reformed
propositions' ought not to keep the festival; those of you who cannot subscribe them,
may." Already the sweet breath of toleration begins to be felt. On St. Vincent's
Eve all the bells were tolled to warn the citizens that tomorrow was the festival
of the patron saint of their city. The dull dawn of a January morning succeeded;
the sacristans made haste to open the gates of the cathedral, to light the tapers,
to prepare the incense, and to set in order the altar-furniture: but, alas! there
came neither, priest nor worshipper at the hour of service. no matins were sung under
the cathedral roof that morning.
The hour of vespers came. The scene of the morning was renewed. No evensong broke
the silence. The organist was seated before his instrument, but he waited in vain
for the coming of canon to mingle his chant, as the wont was, with the peal of the
organ. When he looked about him, half in terror, and contrasted the solitude around
him with the crowd of vested canons and kneeling worshippers, which used on such
occasions to fill choir and nave of the cathedral, and join their voices with the
majestic strains of the Magnificat, his heart was full of sadness; the glory had
departed. He began to play on the organ the Church's mourning hymn, "O wretched
Judas, what hast thou done that thou hast betrayed thy Lord?" and the music
pealed along roof and aisle of the empty church. It sounded like a dirge over the
fall of the Roman worship. "It was the last piece," says Ruchat, "that
was played on that organ, for soon thereafter it was broken in pieces."[15]
The conference was at an end. The Reformers had won an easy victory. Indeed
Zwingli could not help complaining that Eck and other practiced champions on the
Roman side had not been present, in order to permit a fuller development of the strength
of the Protestant argument.[16] Conrad Treger of Friburg, Provincial of the Augustines, did
his best, in the absence of the doctor of Ingolstadt, to maintain the waning glory
and tottering authority of Rome; but it is not surprising that he failed where Eck
himself could not have succeeded. The disputants were restricted to Scripture, and
at this weapon Zwingli excelled all the men of his time.[17]
The theologians had done their part: their Excellencies of Bern must now do
theirs. Assembling the canons and ecclesiastics of the city and canton, the magistrates
asked them if they wished to subscribe the Reformed theses. The response was hearty.
All the canons subscribed the articles, as did also the Prior and Sub-Prior of the
Dominicans, with six: of their brethren, and fifty-two cures and other beneficed
clergy of the city as well as the rural parts.[18]
Having dismissed the members of the conference with honor, defraying the expenses
of those they had specially invited, and appointing a guard of 200 armed men to escort
the Zurich deputies through the territory of the Five Cantons, the magistrates set
about bringing the worship into conformity with the Reformed creed which the clergy
had so unanimously subscribed. The lords in council decreed that the observance of
the mass should cease in Bern, as also in those landward parishes whose cures had
adopted the Reformed confession. The sacrifice abolished, there was no further need
of the altar. The altars were pulled down. A material object of worship stands or
falls with a material sacrifice; and so the images shared the fate of the altars.
Their fragments, strewed on the porch and floor of the churches, were profanely trodden
upon by the feet of those whose knees had so recently been bent in adoration of them.
There were those who witnessed these proceedings with horror, and in whose eyes a
church without an altar and without an image had neither beauty nor sanctity.
"When the good folks of the Oberland come to market," said these men, "they
will be happy to put up their cattle in the cathedral."
An august transaction did that same building – albeit its altars were overturned
and its idols demolished witness on the 2nd of February, 1528. On that day all the
burgesses and inhabitants of Bern, servants as well as masters, were assembled in
the cathedral, at the summons of the magistrates, and swore with uplifted hands to
stand by the council in all their measures for the Reformation of religion.[19] Secured on this
side, the magistrates published an edict on the 7th of February, in thirteen articles,
of which the following are the chief provisions: –
1st. They approved and confirmed the "ten propositions,"
ordaining their subjects to receive and conform themselves to them, and taking God
to witness that they believed them to be agreeable to the Word of God.
2nd. They released their subjects from the jurisdiction of the Bishops of Basle,
Constance, Sion, and Lausanne.
3rd. They discharged the deans and chapters from their oath of obedience, the clergy
from their vow of celibacy, and the people from the law of meats and festivals.
4th. The ecclesiastical goods they apportioned to the payment of annuities to monks
and nuns, to the founding of schools and hospitals, and the relief of the poor. Not
a penny did they appropriate to their own use.[20]
5th. Games of chance they prohibited; the taverns they ordered to be closed
at nine o'clock; houses of infamy they suppressed, banishing their wretched inmates
from the city.[21]
Following in the steps of Zurich, they passed a law forbidding the foreign
service. What deep wounds had that service inflicted on Switzerland! Orphans and
widows, withered and mutilated forms, cowardly feelings, and hideous vices had all
entered with it! Henceforward no Bernese was to be at liberty to sell his sword to
a foreign potentate or shed his own or another's blood in a quarrel that did not
belong to him. In fine, "they made an inscription," says Sleidan, "in
golden letters, upon a pillar, of the day and the year when Popery was abolished,
to stand as a monument to posterity."[22]
The foreign deputies did not depart till they had seen their Excellencies
of Bern honor the occasion of their visit by an act of civic clemency and grace.
They opened the prison doors to two men who had forfeited their lives for sedition.
Further, they recalled all the exiles. "If a king or emperor," said they,
"had visited our city, we would have released the malefactors, exhorting them
to amendment. And now that the King of kings, and the Prince who owns the homage
of our hearts, the Son of God and our Brother, has visited our city, and has opened
to us the doors of an eternal prison, shall we not do honor to him by showing a like
grace to those who have offended against us? " [23]
One other act remained to seal the triumph which the Gospel had won in the
city and canton of Bern. On Easter Sunday the Lord's Supper was celebrated after
what they believed to be the simple model of primitive times. "That Sunday was
a high day." Bern for centuries had been in the tomb of a dark superstition;
but Bern is risen again, and with a calm joy she celebrates, with holy rites, her
return from the grave. Around the great minister lies the hushed city; in the southern
sky stand up the snowy piles of the Oberland, filling the air with a dazzling brightness.
The calm is suddenly broken by the deep tones of the great bell summoning the citizens
to the cathedral. Thither all ranks bend their steps; dressed with ancient Swiss
simplicity, grave and earnest as their fathers were when marching to the battle-field,
they troop in, and now all are gathered under the roof of their ancient minister:
the councilor, the burgess, the artizan; the servant with his master, and by the
side of the hoar patriarch the fresh form and sparkling eye of youth. On that cathedral
floor is now no altar; on its wall no image. No bannered procession advances along
its aisles, and no cloud of incense is seen mounting to its roof; yet never had their
time-honored temple – the house where their fathers had worshipped – appeared more
venerable, and holy, than it did in the eyes of the Bernese this day.
Over the vast assembly rises the pulpit; on it lies the Bible, from which Berthold
Haller is to address to them the words of life. Stretching from side to side of the
building is the Communion table, covered with a linen cloth: the snows of their Alps
are not whiter. The bread and the cup alone are seen on that table. How simple yet
awful these symbols! How full of a gracious efficacy, and an amazing but blessed
import, presenting as they do to the faith of the worshipper that majestic Sufferer,
and that sublime death by which death has been destroyed! The Mighty One, he who
stood before Pilate, but now sitteth on the right hand of God, is present in the
midst of them, seen in the memorials of his passion, and felt by the working of his
Spirit.
The sermon ended, Haller descends from the pulpit, and takes his stand, along with
the elders of the flock, at the Communion table. With eyes and hands lifted up he
gives thanks for this memorial and seal of redemption. Then a hymn, sung in responses,
echoes through the building. How noble and thrilling the melody when with a thousand
tongues a thousand hearts utter their joy! The song is at an end; the hushed stillness
again reigns in aisle and nave of the vast fabric. Hailer takes the bread, and breaking
it in the sight of all, gives it to the communicants, saying, "This is my body;
take, eat." He takes the cup, and says, "This cup is the New Testament
in my blood, shed for you; drink ye all of it." Within that "sign"
lies wrapped up, to their faith, the Divine and everlasting "thing signified."
They receive, with the bread and wine, a full forgiveness, an eternal life – in short,
Christ and the benefits of his redemption. Faith opens the deep fountains of their
soul, their love and sorrow and joy find vent in a flood of tears; scarcely have
these fallen when, like the golden light after the shower, there comes the shout
of gladness, the song of triumph: "They sing a new song, saying, Worthy is the
Lamb that was slain to receive power, and riches, and wisdom, and strength, and honor,
and glory, and blessing: for thou hast redeemed us unto God with thy blood, out of
every kindred, and tongue, and people, and nation: and hast made us unto our God
kings and priests, and we shall reign on the earth."[24] Such was the
worship that succeeded the pantomimic rites and histrionic devotion of the Romish
Church.
CHAPTER 5 Back
to Top
REFORMATION CONSUMMATED IN BASLE.
All Switzerland Moved – The Oberland – Surprise and Anger of its Herdsmen – Basle
– Its Importance – Ecolampadius – Protestants of Basle Petition for Abolition of
Mass – Popular Conflicts – Temporizing Policy of Council – Citizens take Arms – New
Delays by the Council – New Demands of the People – The Night of the 8th of February
– The City Barricaded – Two Thousand Men in Arms – The Senate's Half-concession –
The Idols Broken – Idols of Little Basle – Edict of Senate Establishing the Reform
– Ash-Wednesday – Oath of the People – Exodus of the Priests – Departure of Erasmus.
THE triumph of the Gospel in Bern was felt on sides. It gave new life to the Protestant
movement in every part of the country. On the west it opened the door for the entrance
of the Protestant faith into French-speaking Switzerland. Farel was already in those
parts, and had commenced those labors which we shall afterwards have occasion to
trace to that grand issue to which a greater was destined to conduct them. On the
east, in German Helvetia, the movement, quickened by the impulse communicated from
Bern, was consummated in those towns and villages where for some time it had been
in progress. From the Grisons, on the Italian frontier, to the borders of the Black
Forest, where Basle is washed by the waters of the Rhine, the influence of Bern's
accession was felt, and the Protestant movement quickened.
The great mountains in the center of the land, where the glaciers have their seat,
and the great rivers their birth-place, were alone unmoved. Not unmoved indeed, for
the victory at Bern sent a thrill of surprise and horror through the Oberland. Shut
up with their flocks in the mists and gorges of their mountains, living apart from
the world, spending their days without books, untrained to reflect, nor ever coming
in contact with a new idea, these mountaineers so brave, so independent, but so ignorant
and superstitious, had but one aim, even to abide steadfast to the traditions of
their fathers, and uphold Rome. That Switzerland should abandon the faith it had
held from immemorial times they accounted a shameful and horrible thing. They heard
of the revolution going on in the plains with indignation. A worship without mass,
and a church without an image, were in their eyes no better than atheism. That the
Virgin should be without matins or vespers was simply blasphemy. They trembled to
dwell in a land which such enormities were beginning to pollute. They let drop ominous
threats, which sounded like the mutterings of the thunder before the storm bursts
and discharges its lightning's and hailstones on the plains below. Such a tempest
was soon to break over Switzerland, but first the work of Reformation must proceed
a little further.
Next to Zurich and Bern, Basle was the city of greatest importance in the Swiss Confederacy.
Its numerous and rich foundations, its university, founded as we have said by Eneas
Sylvius, nearly a century before, its many learned men, and its famous printing-presses
enabled it to wield a various and powerful influence. It was the first spot in all
Helvetia on which the Protestant seed had been cast. So early as 1505, we saw Thomas
Wittembach entering its gates, and bringing with him the knowledge of the sacred
tongues, and of that Divine wisdom of which these tongues have been made the vehicle.
A few years later we find Zwingli and Leo Juda sitting at his feet, and listening
to his not yet fully comprehended anticipations of a renovated age and a restored
faith.[1] The seed that fell from the hand of Wittembach was reinforced
by the writings of Luther, which the famous printer Frobenius scattered so plentifully
on this same soil. After this second sowing came the preacher Capito, to be succeeded
by the eloquent Hedio, both of whom watered that seed by their clear and pious expositions
of the Gospels. In 1522, a yet greater evangelist settled in Basle, Ecolampadius,
under whom the Reformation of this important city was destined, after years of waiting
and conflict, to be consummated. Ecolampadius, so scholarly, so meek and pious, was
to the prompt and courageous Zwingli what Melancthon was to Luther.
With all his great parts, Ecolampadius was somewhat deficient in decision and courage.
We have seen him combating alone at Baden in 1526, and at Bern by the side of Zwingli
in 1528, yet all the while he had not taken the decisive step in his own city. Not
that he felt doubt on the question of doctrine; it was the dangers that deterred
him from carrying over Basle to the side of Protestantism. But he came back from
Bern a stronger man. The irresolute evangelist returned the resolved Reformer; and
the learned Basle is now to follow the example of the warlike Bern.
At this time (1528) the Lutherans were in a great majority in Basle. They were 2,500
against 600 Roman Catholics.[2] Tumults were of frequent occurrence, arising out of the religious
differences. On the 23rd December the Reformed assembled without arms, to the number
of 300 and upwards, and petitioned the magistrates to abolish the observance of the
mass, saying that it was "all abomination before God," and asking why "to
please the priests they should draw down his anger on themselves and their children."
They further craved of the magistrates that they should interdict the Pope's preachers,
till "they had proved their doctrine from the Word of God," and they offered
at the same time to take back the mass as soon as the "Roman Catholics had shown
from the Scriptures that it was good," which sounded like a promise to restore
it at the Kalends of April. The Roman Catholics of Little Basle, which lay on the
other bank of the Rhine, and was mostly inhabited by Romanists, assembled in arms,
and strove to obstruct the passage of the petitioners to the town hall. The Senate,
making trial of soft words, advised both parties to retire to their homes, and –
the hour we presume being late – " go to sleep."[3] The council affected
to be neutral, the spirit of Erasmus pervading the higher ranks of Basle. Two days
thereafter, being Christmas Day, both parties again assembled. This time the Reformed
came armed as well as the Roman Catholics. The Roman Catholics were the first to
stir; the terrible news that they were arming circulated from house to house, and
brought out the Lutherans, to the number of about 800. The alarm still flying from
door to door roused others, and at last the number amounted to 3,000. [4] Both parties remained
under arms all night. After four days deliberation, during which the streets were
in a state of tumult, and all the gates were closed except two, which were strongly
guarded, the Senate hit on an expedient which they thought would suffice to restore
the peace between the two parties. They enacted that the "Evangel" should
be preached in all churches, and as regarded mass that every man should be at liberty
to act as his conscience might direct; no one would be prevented giving attendance
on it, and no one would be compelled to do so.
This ordinance made the scales incline on the side of the Reformers. It was a step
in the direction of free preaching and free worship; the Reformed, however, refused
to accept it as a basis of peace. The agitation still continued. Basle wore the appearance
of a camp, which a sudden blow from either side, or a rash word, might at any moment
change into a battle-field. News of what was going on in Basle flew through the Confederation.
From both the Reformed and Popish cantons came deputies to offer their meditation.
It was whispered among the Roman Catholics that the Lutherans were bringing in their
confederates to fight for them. This rumor raised their fury to a yet higher pitch.
A war of hearths seemed imminent. The Senate made another attempt to restore the
peace. They decreed that a public disputation on the mass should take place on the
second Sabbath after Pentecost, and that meanwhile in three of the churches only
should mass be celebrated, and that only one mass a day should be said, high mass
namely.[5] Now, thought the magistrates, we have found the means of
restoring calm to the agitated waters. Basle will resume its lettered quiet.
These hopes were doomed to be disappointed. The publication of the edict evoked a
greater tempest than ever. On the reading of it, loud and vehement voices resounded
on both sides. "No mass – no mass – not even a single one – we will die sooner."[6] Counter-shouts were raised by the Romanists. "We are
ready to die for the mass," cried they, waving their arms menacingly to add
to the vehemence of their voices; "if they reject the mass – to arms! to arms!"[7]
The magistrates were almost at their wit's end. Their temporizing, instead
of appeasing the tempest, was but lashing it into greater fury. They hit on another
device, which but showed that their stock of expedients was nearly exhausted. They
forbade the introduction of the German psalms into those churches where it had not
been the wont to sing them.[8] It was hardly to be expected that so paltry a concession
would mollify the Roman Catholics.
The Romish party, fearing that the day was going against them, had recourse to yet
more violent measures. They refused the decree to hold a disputation on the mass
after Pentecost. One thing was clear to them, that whether the mass was founded on
the Word of God or not, it attracted to Basle large sums from the Popish districts,
every penny of which would be cut off were it abolished. Seeing then, if its proof
were dubious, its profit was most indubitable, they were resolved to uphold it, and
would preach it more zealously than ever. The pulpits began to thunder against heresy;
Sebastien Muller, preacher in the Cathedral of St. Peter, mounted the pulpit on the
24th January, 1529, and losing his head, at no time a cool one, in the excess of
his zeal, he broke out in a violent harangue, and poured forth a torrent of abusive
epithets and sarcastic mockeries against the Reformed. His sermon kindled into rage
the mass of his hearers, and some Lutherans who were present in the audience were
almost in risk of being torn in pieces.[9]
This fresh outbreak quickened the zeal on the other side, not indeed into
violence, but activity. The Reformed saw that the question must be brought to an
issue, either for or against the mass, and that until it was so their lives would
not be safe in Basle. They, accordingly, charged their committee to carry their complaint
to the Senate, and to demand that the churches should be provided with "good
preachers" who would "proclaim to them the pure Word of God." Their
Excellencies received them graciously, and promised them a favorable answer. The
magistrates were still sailing on two tacks.[10]
Fifteen days passed away, but there came no answer from the Senate. Meanwhile,
a constant fire of insults, invectives, and sanguinary menaces was kept up by the
Roman Catholics upon the Reformed, which the latter bore with wonderful patience
seeing that they formed the vast majority of the citizens, and that those who assailed
them with these taunts and threatenings were mostly the lower orders from the suburb
of the Little Basle. The Reformed began to suspect the Senate of treachery; and seeing
no ending to the affair but a bloody encounter, in which one of the two parties would
perish, they convoked an assembly of the adherents of the Reformation. On the 8th
February, 800 men met in the Church of the Franciscans, and after prayer to God,
that he would direct them to those measures that would be for his glory, they entered
on their deliberations.
To the presence of "the fathers and relatives of the priests" in the council
they attributed that halting policy which had brought Basle to the edge of an abyss,
mad resolved, as the only effectual cure, that the council should be asked to purge
itself.[11] They agreed, moreover, that the election of the senators
henceforward should be on a democratic basis – above-board, and in the hands of the
people.
"Tomorrow," said the council, somewhat startled, "we will give you
an answer."
"Your reply," rejoined the citizens, "must be given tonight."
No eyes were to be closed that night in Basle. The Senate had been sitting all day.
There was time for an answer, yet none had been forthcoming. They had been put off
till tomorrow. What did that mean? Was it not possible that the intervening night
would give birth to some dark plot which the Senate might even now be hatching against
the public safety? They were 1,200 men, all well armed. They sent again to the council-hall
to say, "Tonight, not tomorrow, we must have your answer." It was nine
of the evening. The Senate replied that at so late an hour they could not decide
on a matter of so great moment, but that to-morrow they should without fail give
their answer, and meanwhile they begged the citizens to retire in peace to their
homes.[12]
The citizens resolved not to separate. On the contrary they sent once more,
and for the last time, to the Senate, to demand their answer that very night. Their
Excellencies thought good no longer to trifle with the armed burghers. Longer delay
might bring the whole 1,200 warriors into the Senate House. To guard against an irruption
so formidable, they sent a messenger when near midnight to say that all members of
Senate who were relatives of priests would be excluded from that body, and as to
the rest of their demands, all things touching religion and policy would be regulated
according to their wish.[13]
The answer was so far satisfactory; but the citizens did not view it as a
concession of their demands in full. Their enemies might yet spring a mine upon them;
till they had got something more than a promise, they would not relax their vigilance
or retire to their dwellings. Dividing themselves into three companies they occupied
three different quarters of the city.
They planted six pieces of cannon before the Hotel de Ville; they barricaded the
streets by drawing chains across them; they took possession of the arsenal; they
posted strong guards at the gates and in the towers on the wall; and kindling immense
torches of fir-trees, they set them on high places to dispel with their flickering
beams the darkness that brooded over the city. So passed the night of the 8th February,
1529, in Basle.
The leaders of the Romanists began to quail before the firm attitude of the citizens.
The burgomaster, Henry Meltinger with his son-in-law, and several councilors, stole,
under cover of the darkness, to the Rhine, and embarking in one of the boats that
lay moored on its banks, made their escape on its rapid current. Their flight, which
became known over-night, increased the popular uneasiness and suspicion. "They
are gone to fetch the Austrians," said the people. "Let us make ready against
their return." When day broke they had 2,000 men in arms.[14]
At eight in the morning the Senate sent to the committee of the citizens to
say that they had designated twelve senators, who were to absent themselves when
religious affairs were treated of, but that the men so designated refused to submit
unconditionally, and had appealed their cause for a hearing before the other cantons.
The citizens were willing to meet them there, but on this condition, that the appellants
paid their own expenses, seeing they were prosecuting their own private quarrel,
whereas the citizens defending the cause of the commonwealth and posterity were entitled
to have their charges defrayed from the public treasury.[15] On this point
the Senate sat deliberating till noon without coming to any conclusion. Again the
cry of treachery was raised. The patience of the burghers was exhausted. They sent
a detachment of forty men to inspect all the posts in the city in case of surprise.
The troops marched straight to the Cathedral of St. Peter. One of them raising his
halberd struck a blow with all his force on a side door. It was that of a closet
in which the idols had been stowed away. The door was shivered; one of the images
tumbled out, and was broken in pieces on the stony floor. A beginning having been
made, the idols, one after another, were rolled out, and soon a pile of fragments
– heads, trunks, and limbs – covered the floor. Erasmus wondered that "they
wrought no miracle to save themselves, for if all accounts were true, prodigies had
been done on more trivial occasions."
The priests raised an outcry, and attempted resistance, but this only hastened the
consummation they deplored. The people came running to the cathedral. The priests
fled before the hurricane that had swept into the temple, and shutting themselves
up in the vestry, listened with dismay and trembling, as one and another of the idols
was overturned, and crash succeeded crash; the altars were demolished, the pictures
were torn down, and the fragments being carried out and piled up, and set on fire
in the open squares, continued to burn till far in the evening, the citizens standing
round and warming their hands at the blaze in the chilly air. The Senate, thinking
to awe the excited and insurgent citizens, sent to ask them what they did. "We
are doing in an hour," said they, "what you have not been able to do in
three years."[16]
The iconoclasts made the round of Basle, visiting all its churches, and destroying
with pike and axe all the images they found. The Romanists of Little Basle, knowing
the storm that was raging on the other side of the Rhine, and fearing that it would
cross the bridge to their suburb, so amply replenished with sacred shrines, offered
to purge their churches with their own hands. The images of Little Basle were more
tenderly dealt with than those of St. Peter's and other city churches. Their worshippers
carried them reverently to upper rooms and garrets, and hid them, in the hope that
when better times returned they would be able to bring them out of the darkness,
and set them up in their old places. The suburban idols thus escaped the cremation
that overtook their less fortunate brethren of St. Ulric and St. Alban.[17]
The magistrates of Basle, deeming it better to march in the van of a Reform
than be dragged at the tail of a revolution, now granted all the demands of the citizens.
They enacted, 1st, that the citizens should vote in the election of the members of
the two councils; 2ndly, that from this day the idols and mass should be abolished
in the city and the canton, and the churches provided with good ministers to preach
the Word of God; 3rdly, that in all matters appertaining to religion and the commonweal,
260 of the members of the guilds should be admitted to deliberate with the Senate.[18] The people had carried the day. They had secured the establishment
of the Protestant worship, and they had placed the State on a constitutional and
popular basis. Such were the triumphs of these two eventful days. The firmness of
the people had overcome the neutrality of the Senate, the power of the hierarchy,
the disfavor of the learned, and had achieved the two liberties without shedding
a drop of blood. "The commencement of the Reformation at Basle," says Ruchat,
"was not a little tumultuous, but its issue was happy, and all the troubles
that arose about religion were terminated without injury to a single citizen in his
life or goods."
The third day, 10th of February, was Ash-Wednesday. The men of Basle resolved that
their motto that day should be "Ashes to ashes." The images that had escaped
cremation on the evening of the 8th were collected in nine piles and burned on the
Cathedral Square.[19] The Romanists, Ecolampadius informs us, "turned away
their eyes, shuddering with horror." Others remarked, "the idols are keeping
their Ash-Wednesday." The idols had the mass as their companion in affliction,
fragments of the demolished altars having been burned in the same fires.
On Friday, 12th of February, all the trades of the city met and approved the edict
of the Senate, as an "irrevocable decree," and on the following day they
took the oath, guild by guild, of fidelity to the new order of things. On next Sunday,
in all the churches, the Psalms were chanted in German, in token of their joy.[20]
This revolution was followed by an exodus of priests, scholars, and monks.
The rushing Rhine afforded all facilities of transport. No one fled from dread of
punishment, for a general amnesty, covering all offenses, had set all fears at rest.
It was dislike of the Protestant faith that made the fugitives leave this pleasant
residence. The bishop, carrying with him his title but not his jurisdiction, fixed
his residence at Poirentru. The monks peaceably departed "with their harems"[21] to Friburg. Some of the chairs in the university were vacated,
but new professors, yet more distinguished, came to fill them; among whom were Oswald
Myconius, Sebastien Munster, and Simon Grynaeus. Last and greatest, Erasmus too departed.
Basle was his own romantic town; its cathedral towers, its milky river, the swelling
hills, with their fir-trees, all were dear to him. Above all, he took delight in
the society of its dignified clergy, its polite scholars, and the distinguished strangers
who here had gathered round him. From Basle this monarch of the schools had ruled
the world of letters. But Protestantism had entered it, and he could breathe its
air no longer. He must endure daily mortification's on those very streets where continual
incense had been offered to him; and rather than do so he would leave the scene of
his glory, and spend the few years that might yet remain to him elsewhere.
Embarking on the Rhine in presence of the magistrates and a crowd of citizens, who
had assembled to do him honor, he spoke his adieu to his much-loved Basle as the
boat was unmooring: "Jam Basilea vale!"[22] (Basle, farewell,
farewell!) and departed for Friburg, in Brisgau.[23]
CHAPTER 6 Back
to Top
LEAGUE OF THE FIVE CANTONS WITH AUSTRIA — SWITZERLAND DIVIDED.
The Light Spreading — The Oberland in Darkness — The Gospel Invades the Mountains
— League of the Five Cantons with Austria — Persecution Begun — Martyrdom of Pastor
Keyser — The Christian Coburghery — The Breach among the Swiss Cantons Widening —
Dean Bullinger — The Men of Gaster — Idols that won't March — Violence of the Popish
Cantons — Effort of Zurich to Avert War-The Attempt Abortive — War Proclaimed — Zwingli's
Part in the Affair — Was it Justifiable?
IT is a great crime to force an entrance for the truth by the sword, and compel
unwilling necks to bow to it. It is not less a crime to bar its path by violence
when it is seeking to come in by legitimate and peaceable means. This was the error
into which the five primitive cantons of Switzerland now changed. Their hardy inhabitants,
as they looked down from under the overhanging glaciers and icy pinnacles of their
great mountains, beheld the new faith spreading over the plains at their feet. It
had established itself in Zurich; the haughty lords of Bern had welcomed it; Schaffhausen
and St. Gall had opened their gates to it; and even Basle, that abode of scholars,
had turned from Plato and Aristotle, to sit at the feet of apostles. Along the chain
of the Jura, by the shores of the Leman, to the very gates of a city as yet immersed
in darkness, but destined soon to become the brightest luminary in that brilliant
constellation, was the light travelling. But the mountains of the Oberland, which
are the first to catch the natural day, and to flash their early fires all over Switzerland,
were the last to be touched with the Reformed dawn now rising on Christendom. With
the light brightening all round, they remained in the darkness.
The herdsmen of these cantons saw with grief and alarm the transformation which was
passing upon their country. The glory was departing from it. They felt only horror
as messenger after messenger arrived in their mountains and told them what was transacting
on the plains below; that the altars at which their fathers had worshipped were being
cast down; that the images to which they had bent the knee were being flung into
the flames; that priest and monk were being chased away; that the light of holy taper
was being extinguished, and that silence was falling on those holy orisons whose
melodies welcomed the morn and greeted the departure of the day; that all those rites
and customs, in short, which, were wont to beautify and sanctify their land were
being abolished, and a defiling and defiant heresy was rearing its front in their
stead. The men of the Forest Cantons learned with yet greater indignation and dismay
that this pestilent faith had come to their very gates, and was knocking for admission.
Nay, it was even penetrating into their grand valleys. This was not to be borne.
They must make haste, for soon their own altars would be overturned, their crucifixes
trampled in the mire, and the light of their holy tapers extinguished. They resolved
to oppose the entrance of the Reformation as they would that of the plague; but they
could oppose it by the only means of resistance which they understood the faggot
and the sword.
Their alarm was intensified when they learned that Protestantism, performing a flank
movement, was attacking them in the rear. It had crossed the Alps, and was planting
itself in Italy. There was at that time (1530) a little band of Carmelite monks in
Locarno, on the fertile and lovely shores of Lake Maggiore, who had come to the knowledge
of a free salvation, and who, under the protection of Zurich, whose suzerainty then
extended to that part of Italy, were laboring to initiate the Reformation of their
native land. The men of the Five Cantons saw themselves about to be isolated, shut
up in their mountains, cut off even from Italy, the cradle of their faith. They could
sit still no longer.
But whither shall they turn? They could not wage war themselves against the Reformed
cantons. These cantons were superior in men and money, and they could not hope to
cope successfully with them. They must seek other allies. By doing so they would
break the league of brotherhood with the other cantons, for they had resigned the
right of forming new alliances without the consent of all the other members of the
Federation; but they hoped to conduct the negotiations in secret. They turned their
eyes to Austria. This was the last quarter from which a Swiss canton might have been
expected to seek help. Had they forgotten the grievous yoke that Austria had made
them bear in other days? Had they forgotten the blood it cost their fathers to break
that yoke? Were they now to throw away what they had fought for on the gory fields
of Morgarten and Sempach? They were prepared to do this. Religious antipathy overcame
national hatred; terror of Protestantism suspended their dread of their traditional
foe. Even Austria was astonished, and for awhile was in doubt of the good faith of
the Five Cantons. They were in earnest, however, and the result was that a league
was concluded, and sworn to on both sides, the 23rd of April, 1529, at Waldshut.[1] The Switzer of Unterwalden and Uri mounted the peacock's
feather, the Austrian badge, and grasped in friendship the hands of the men with
whom his fathers had contended to the death. The leading engagement in the league
was that all attempts at forming new sects in the Five Cantons should be punished
with death, and that Austria should give her aid, if need were, by sending the Five
Cantons 6,000 foot-soldiers, and 400 horse, with the proper complement of artillery.
It was further agreed that, if the war should make it necessary, the Reformed cantons
should be blockaded, and all provisio